I normally make my own sauce, but in a pinch this upstate New York produced sauce trumps any other jar.
I can never find it in the grocery store, but on a lucky day I can find it at Homegoods, Marshall's or TJ Maxx, and when I do, I clear the shelf.
It is made in Liverpool though, so for my NY friends, you might have better luck at the stores up near the 'Cuse.
For everyone else, keep your eyes out for this sauce. You won't be disappointed.
Oh, and Wegman's?! Another shout-out for upstate!
And ps. 'upstate' doesn't mean White Plains. There is actually an entire state on top of NYC.